Cisco’s March Madness
I am told that my 5 foot 5 grandmother was a basketball star in high school. The story goes that she racked up many points per game and may have even made some records. I am pretty sure that if she played Jeremy Lin today, she would not be able to keep those records.
The point here is simple: You need to differentiate between adding up records from the beginning of time vs. counting the number of current records.
Last week, Cisco announced new UCS systems, claiming 63 industry benchmark world records overall. Here’s what you need to know:
- Cisco claims 63 UCS records and provides a link. The link goes to a document which lists 50 proof points. If you’re claiming 63 records, it would be good to see 63 records.
- Almost a quarter of these “records” are one benchmark and one benchmark only — a virtualization benchmark which only highlights very limited performance ability using a very specific set of products. Not quite the “breadth” that Cisco claims.
- Some of the results cited are records purely because they were “first to market.” So Cisco was merely first to publish a result on a certain benchmark in a certain category — and may have only been the best for a short while because they were first.
- Finally, and most importantly, here’s the clincher, so pay really close attention. Cisco’s claimed “records” are “Record as of Publication Date.” This means that Cisco counts records and puts notches in their belt if they have a result that has ever been on top, even for a day over the last three years. The real question is how many of those 63 benchmark results are currently #1 ? . . . For many, many years IBM has published web pages with #1 Power benchmarks. With over 100 #1 benchmarks. These over 100 benchmarks are all benchmarks where IBM is currently #1. At the moment in time. Not #1’s culled from all time. I know this. I know this because I personally and painstakingly have to update these very pages.
I would love to see a count of how many records IBM would have if they included #1’s from the beginning of time. I would love to see my grandmother on the court with Jeremy Lin. But I just can’t fathom the awesomeness of either.
The postings on this site solely reflect the personal views of the author and do not necessarily represent the views, positions, strategies or opinions of IBM or IBM management.